Silk Road forums

Discussion => Silk Road discussion => Topic started by: Tessellated on October 07, 2013, 05:36 pm

Title: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: Tessellated on October 07, 2013, 05:36 pm
I would be just wonderful if anyone has access to a backup of the Silk Road and could extract everyone's feedback. If each person's feedback could be PGP signed by a trusted MOD then that would help a lot too.

I have created an archive of all of my review threads but I feel the loss of thousands of vendor's feedback is a great loss to the web of trust that was built. The huge collection of feedback was what made the Silk Road great, it showed who was to be trusted and who was not. Trust is the key factor in this type of business.

This information would be a great aid in the idea and ideals of the Silk Road surviving the death of the Silk Road.
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: EyeManIFest on October 07, 2013, 05:49 pm
If only vendor feedback could be traded like torrents.. that would be awesome.
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: Tessellated on October 07, 2013, 06:11 pm
If only vendor feedback could be traded like torrents.. that would be awesome.

If every user registered a public key when they joined a market, and they signed their feedback with that key then feedback could be shared between multiple marketplaces.

The next best thing would be for the feedbacks to be signed by the market itself.
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: Burning Babylon on October 07, 2013, 07:01 pm
If only vendor feedback could be traded like torrents.. that would be awesome.

If every user registered a public key when they joined a market, and they signed their feedback with that key then feedback could be shared between multiple marketplaces.

The next best thing would be for the feedbacks to be signed by the market itself.

Interesting notion but are you referring to a Key System here or buyers manually signing their reviews with a PGP Key? I'm assuming you're referring to the first option as there's no way buyers would take the time to sign with PGP keys - anyway so I'm just thinking openly here about how that could possibly work:

* If the feedback is stored on a third party site how long would it be valid and could it be accessed by anyone?
* Certain parameters could be added to the Feedback which would only make it possible for the Vendor the feedback was intended for to use it on their profile.
* The Feedback System could work both ways for a way for Vendors to quickly warn other Venders of troublesome Customers.
* If a key is used to unlock the Feedback some system would have to be in place so two Vendors or more can't utilize the "same" Feedback at the same time.
* As some Sites have different rules the "Type of Transaction" could be included in the Feedback, i.e conventional/escrow, FE, Lottery and so on.

Sure it could be refined significantly with some thought but definitely interesting idea. :)
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: midlandsmafia on October 07, 2013, 07:05 pm
Try this
*CLEARNET* https://anonfiles.com/file/6b1af107c71884fc3de0b5173cca8fd6
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: Bungee54 on October 07, 2013, 07:07 pm
BB you have our greatest respect..you are doing these things we always wanted to :)

And your analytical abilities are excellent.

Keep up the good work !

please send us an email and you key to ponderingthoughts@safe-mail.net

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.19 (GNU/Linux)
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==
=kqJK
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----




Cheers!
Title: Re: Is there a backup of the Silk Road feedback?
Post by: muskabuzz on October 07, 2013, 11:44 pm
Thanks to the characteristically helpful Libertas for the vendor profile linked below.

Is there any backup of the listings or the individual feedback?


The resilience, intelligence, and imagination of this community warms our hearts; thank you for it.

Muskabuzz