Silk Road forums

Support => Feature requests => Topic started by: Cannaisseur on August 18, 2013, 06:14 pm

Title: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: Cannaisseur on August 18, 2013, 06:14 pm
Too many extortionist changing their feedback for free product, reships, and refunds.

Enough is enough.

Feedback should be permanent once left, that way no extortion.
Title: Re: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: james frazer on August 19, 2013, 10:32 pm
Feedback should be permanent once left, that way no extortion.

If it was not possible to update feedback then buyers would have to choose between leaving feedback on delivery speed, stealth and quantity when they first receive the goods, or waiting to leave feedback that included quality until after the goods had been sampled or tested, which might not be for several weeks. This might lead to less current feedback and/or less feedback containing details about product purity.
Title: Re: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: crystal on August 25, 2013, 06:58 pm

If it was not possible to update feedback then buyers would have to choose between leaving feedback on delivery speed, stealth and quantity when they first receive the goods, or waiting to leave feedback that included quality until after the goods had been sampled or tested, which might not be for several weeks. This might lead to less current feedback and/or less feedback containing details about product purity.

Agree on this, a way to leave a comment about product quality later on is important...
Title: Re: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: plainsman1963 on August 25, 2013, 07:17 pm
Too many extortionist changing their feedback for free product, reships, and refunds.

Enough is enough.

Feedback should be permanent once left, that way no extortion.
Ask and ye shall receive:
ok, we're ready to push out the next update.  I'll be closing the site for an hour or two while we do this.

In this update we'll see a few changes.

When you have finalized your order, you won't have to leave a review or a rating.  When leaving a rating, you will see phrases next to the 1 - 5 scores giving you a sense of what they represent.  If you have unreviewed transactions with a vendor, a link will appear on their page where you can leave a review.  Reviews on a vendors page now have the buyer's stats, and the transaction stats.  A vendor's rating widget links to a dedicated ratings and reviews page where you can see a breakdown of a vendors ratings, both weighted and unweighted, along with all of their reviews broken down by 1 - 5 groups.  Also, all ratings and reviews will be final and uneditable.  That means, if you have not received your order or tested it, you should not rate or review it!  Oh yea, and you'll be able to sort reviews by weight or freshness.  I hope you enjoy it!

Once we get this pushed out and running smoothly, we'll move on to the next phase which will be looking at giving vendors more tools to judge buyers and protect themselves from scamming buyers.
http://dkn255hz262ypmii.onion/index.php?topic=207090.msg1486439;topicseen#new
Title: Re: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: Cannaisseur on August 25, 2013, 07:43 pm
I was about to post that link, i was logged in when in went down for maintenance

Finally a update for the sellers
Title: Re: Make Feedback Permanent
Post by: ~o~WaterWalker~o~ on August 26, 2013, 03:36 am
Too many extortionist changing their feedback for free product, reships, and refunds.

Enough is enough.

Feedback should be permanent once left, that way no extortion.

this is stupid - just ignore them and stop selling to them.    Perfect stats is fake anyway

some reason this got a lot of traction but will bring unintended consequences